I'm considering placing my granny square quilt blocks on point. I think they look more like crocheted granny squares that way. But I love them the other way too. Thank goodness I still have some time before I have to decide.
If I place the blocks on point, I'll need 63 whole blocks instead of the 80 I'll need the other way. But the on-point layout will require several half blocks to fill in around the edges. So probably about the same amount of sewing.
Which do you like best?
Grannies or Point?
Or Grannies this Way?
This post was migrated from the old blog. To see the comments on the original post, CLICK HERE. To add a new comment, click "Post a Comment", below.
On 03/18/2013, Joanne said ...
I like the original set. I like them both, but prefer the one in the second photo.
On 03/18/2013, Nancy in Utah said ...
Both settings are really pretty, but I like the 'on point' the best. I think because when I was 8 years old, my grandmother helped me put together my first crocheted Granny Square afghan and though I didn't know it had a design name, she had me sew the squares together in an 'on point' setting and it was gorgeous. So I'm a little bit biased, LOL. Gorgeous blocks Susan, in either setting. Hugs...
On 03/18/2013, Jan said ...
I like on point, but that's because mine are set that way! Whichever way you choose, they'll be pretty! You can't go wrong!
On 03/18/2013, Barbara Anne said ...
I like both settings, too, but am a bit more partial to the straight set. Your quilt will be delightful no matter which setting you choose because your Granny Squares are so happy!
If you go with the pretty on-point option, I'd use setting triangles instead of partial Granny Squares. If you used a light fabric similar to your background fabric for the setting triangles, your Granny Squares would appear to float within the border(s).
This is one thing I love about quilting: ALL of the choices from block to fabrics, to color placement, to setting, to borders, backing, and binding, are up to you. Sheer creative freedom!
Hugs!
On 03/18/2013, Julie in WA said ...
I don't think you can go wrong setting the blocks either way...they look so pretty! But I do like the straight setting more than the on-point setting.
On 03/18/2013, Sue, the Florida Farm Girl said ...
On point, without a doubt. Once you do the calculations right for the setting triangles, its not too bad. But sometimes I just don't want to bother with the on point, so do it the other way. Whichever you choose will be wonderful.
On 03/18/2013, Sandra Neel Hutchins said ...
The fun is in the creativity! So YOU enjoy choosing. I like the straight set better. Either way, of course, the colors will create such a peaceful, and at the same time, perky quilt.
On 03/18/2013, Helen in Switzerland said ...
I like both settings - but isn't it amazing how different from each other they look!
On 03/18/2013, Teresa said ...
I like the straight set - Granny's way. Its going to be a fantastic quilt whichever way you choose.
On 03/18/2013, RED GERANIUM COTTAGE said ...
I love both ways but I think straight is what I like. The blocks are so pretty.
On 03/18/2013, Sue said ...
I always think on point looks cleaner and more interesting. I make a lot of 9 patch scrap blocks and always turn them on point.
On 03/18/2013, Ellen in Oregon said ...
I am a bit partial to the on point because you get a more intresting & complex secondary designs. I totally agree with Barbara Anne that if you do them on point I would would use a light tonal fabric for the setting squares rather than Half blocks. I love it when the blocks appear to float in space. I guess the straight set is great if you want a simple quieter traditional look & the on-point is more complex, pops the colors & has greater depth to it.
You've made great progress with the blocks and should be very pleased with how great the colors look. Can't wait to see what you decide.No matter what you do, it is going to be beautiful. Granny on!
On 03/18/2013, Deb said ...
I'd pick on point...just seems to look classier! :) They're all beautiful, Susan.
On 03/18/2013, Linda said ...
At first I thought I like the straight set best (I love them both), but I have to say the colors really jump out at me on-point. Plus I agree with you that they look more like crocheted granny squares on-point. They are really beautiful.
How are you feeling - hope you heard from your doctor today and that it was good news.
On 03/19/2013, Laura said ...
I am 100% a on point vote. I agree it looks more crocheted on point. Hugs
-----
No comments:
Post a Comment